Concept Selection

In order to determine which concept was most viable, we performed a Pugh analysis on the three concepts based on the aforementioned criteria in the Concept Generation Diagram.
From Pugh analysis we concluded that the Excel tool would be best, in terms of functionality and feasibility, as our final deliverable. 

Pugh Diagram analysis for the 3 concepts suggested that

Concept 1: Excel tool would be best as our final deliverable.